Eminem’s Year-End Chart Drama: “Curtain Call” Shines While “The Death of Slim Shady” Gets Snubbed

Eminem’s legacy as one of rap’s most iconic artists is undeniable, but even legends face head-scratching moments. As 2024 wraps up, Billboard and HitsDailyDouble have left fans puzzled over conflicting data about Eminem’s chart performance this year.

The rapper’s 2005 greatest hits album, Curtain Call: The Hits, is projected to rank No. 38 on Billboard’s Year-End Top 200 Albums for 2024, pulling in a staggering 920,000 units. Meanwhile, Eminem’s 2024 release, The Death of Slim Shady, failed to crack Billboard’s Top 50 despite solid sales.

The plot thickens when HitsDailyDouble enters the picture. Their YTD Overall Activity ranking places The Death of Slim Shady at No. 32 with 931,837 units sold, outpacing Curtain Call: The Hits, which lands at No. 37 with 877,525 units. The conflicting rankings have left fans scratching their heads.

Here’s how the other rap heavyweights fared on Billboard’s Year-End Top 50 chart:

• No. 5: For All The Dogs – Drake (2.21M units)
• No. 15: We Don’t Trust You – Future & Metro Boomin (1.4M units)
• No. 16: Utopia – Travis Scott (1.39M units)
• No. 30: Pink Friday – Nicki Minaj (990K units)
• No. 32: American Dream – 21 Savage (960K units)
• No. 38: Curtain Call: The Hits – Eminem (920K units)

While Curtain Call cements its place as a perennial fan favorite, The Death of Slim Shady seems to be overlooked by Billboard despite better sales data from HitsDailyDouble. Could it be a difference in tracking methods or something more? The mystery adds intrigue to a year where Eminem’s legacy shone brightly despite polarizing reception to his new music.